Bags & Totes(576)
Belts(215)
Breeches(1,614)
Equestrian Gloves(1,445)
Equestrian Jewelry(423)
Equestrian Riding Helmets(1,495)
Footwear(1,749)
Half Chaps & Chaps(592)
Hats & Headbands(58)
Horse Show Apparel(1,311)
Outerwear(402)
Protective Vests(133)
Rider Therapeutics(238)
Undergarments(480)
Shop Now At SmartPak
Casual Footwear & Accessories or
Choose a Category
- Shop Barn and Stable Supplies
- Shop Cotton Leads
- Shop Daily Dewormer
- Shop Dog & Cat Products
- Shop Dog Cardiovascular Support Supplements
- Shop Fleece Jackets
- Shop Fleeces
- Shop Gifts, Books & DVDs
- Shop Halter Accessories
- Shop Horse Health Care Products
- Shop Horse Supplements
- Shop Horse Tack, Supplies and Equipment
- Shop Jackets
- Shop Leather Halters
- Shop Leather Leads
- Shop Long Sleeve Shirts
- Shop Most Wished For
- Shop New Products
- Shop Nylon Halters
- Shop Nylon Leads
- Shop Outerwear Accessories
- Shop Pants
- Shop Personalized Outerwear
- Shop Personalized Shirts
- Shop Rain and Winter Pants
- Shop Rider Apparel & Gear
- Shop Rope Halters
- Shop Sale
- Shop Short Sleeve Shirts
- Shop Soft Shell Jackets
- Shop Sweaters
- Shop Sweatshirts
- Shop Three Season Outerwear
- Shop Trail Riding
- Shop Trail of Painted Ponies
- Shop Vests
- Shop Water-resistant Outerwear
- Shop Waterproof Outerwear
- Shop Western Dee Bits
- Shop Winter Riding Gear
Top-Rated Products
Reviews Home >
Rider Apparel & Gear Reviews >
Footwear Reviews >
Casual Footwear & Accessories Reviews
Customer Reviews for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
The newest of the Mountain Horse winter boot. The Stella Polaris is fashionably chic as well as functional, meticulously designed for a comfortable fit and superior traction on ice and snow. Regular Calf Size. Sizes 6-10.Built in steel shank for increased stability while walking or riding. Specially slim and contoured designed outsole made especially for riding.
Average Customer Rating:
(31 Reviews) 29
Rating breakdown 31 reviews
5 Stars
20
4 Stars
6
3 Stars
4
2 Stars
1
1 Star
0
27 of 31(87%)of customers would recommend this product to a friend.
Customer Reviews for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Review 1 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
COGDI
March 27, 2013
ByCOGDI
fromColorado
Expertise:Intermediate
Riding Style:Leisure/Trail Riding - English
Competitor:Non-competitor
Quality:
5
of
5
Value:
4
of
5
Durability:
4
of
5
Share this Review:
"The daughter not only loves these for riding but also for shoveling snow or other chores. Wish it came in my (calf) size!"
Review 2 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Awkward Fit
March 3, 2013
ByPonyGoCrazy
fromAiken, SC
I have used this product for:less than a month
Expertise:Intermediate
Riding Style:Eventing
Competitor:Rated
Quality:
5
of
5
Value:
3
of
5
Durability:
4
of
5
Fit
Runs small
Runs large
Runs small
Share this Review:
"I am SO disapointed in these!!!! I am probably the biggest promoter of Mountain Horse. I have returned every tall boot I've ever ordered only to always go back to Mountain Horse Tall Boots! I love love love my show and training tall boots but these I HATE. I tried them in a 8.5 and the calf was so tight because they put the stretch material on the side instead of in the back (where it needs to be). I couldn't zip it up. Then I ordered a 9 thinking it would fit. Once I realized I could grab the side and pull at the same time, I got it to zip up. Now the other issue... these are so bulky I can't even move around in the flat. I feel like I'm riding with blocks below my waist. I gave them a full three weeks to make sure I felt this way and I still do. The foot is super bulky and the calf is much too snug. It is just wrong and un-proportioned. I'm never even going to use them again and I feel like I could have spent the money on regular tall boots. I LOVE LOVE LOVE mountain horse! But these are horribly designed!
If you are a rider who rides in the mountains in the deep snow they will probably work for you - but as a rider in training they do didly squat for me. I'm going back to my old old old MH boots and just wearing wool socks with them."
Products related to my content
Review 3 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Toasty toes!
January 26, 2013
ByDD05
Expertise:Intermediate
Quality:
5
of
5
Value:
5
of
5
Fit
Runs small
Runs large
Runs large
Share this Review:
"This is the first winter riding boot I've purchased... and I don't know why I waited so long. These were comfortable from the moment I put them on. The break at the ankle softened while I was walking around the house. They are warm... and for a winter boot, stylish. I don't know how durable they will be, so I left that blank. And, they do run large."
Review 4 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Good Winter Boot
January 23, 2013
ByCLIN
fromCumberland, MD
I have used this product for:1-3 months
Expertise:Novice
Riding Style:Hunter/Jumper
Competitor:Non-competitor
Quality:
4
of
5
Value:
4
of
5
Durability:
4
of
5
Fit
Runs small
Runs large
Runs large
Share this Review:
"These boots are sized large. I would buy one size smaller than your normal boot size.
They are comfortable and warm. For leisurely riding they are a must in the winter. To train in, not so hot. They are a bit bulky. I find it hard to use dressage methods because of the bulkiness. Perhaps an advanced rider might be more successful. They are good looking and are a nice quality. A tad pricey."
They are comfortable and warm. For leisurely riding they are a must in the winter. To train in, not so hot. They are a bit bulky. I find it hard to use dressage methods because of the bulkiness. Perhaps an advanced rider might be more successful. They are good looking and are a nice quality. A tad pricey."
Review 5 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Great winter boot
January 22, 2013
Bymalyons76
fromRochester, NY
I have used this product for:1-3 months
Expertise:Intermediate
Riding Style:Hunter/Jumper
Competitor:Rated
Quality:
5
of
5
Value:
3
of
5
Durability:
5
of
5
Share this Review:
"I hesitated after reading the reviews about the height of these boots but I really wanted something I could wear over my jeans when it got really cold. I am 5'4" and when I first put them on they were really high and hurt as I drove in my car to the barn. However, after one ride they broke in nicely and settled right down below my knee. They are super comfortable and warm and I wear them all day working and riding. Sometimes the zipper can be tough to get up but for durability it has to be."
Review 6 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
These are WONDERFUL! Plus sized riders, GET THESE!
January 21, 2013
ByBelleCavaliere
fromRosebush
I have used this product for:less than a month
Expertise:Intermediate
Riding Style:Dressage
Competitor:Non-competitor
Quality:
5
of
5
Value:
4
of
5
Durability:
4
of
5
Share this Review:
"I got to ride in these for the first time last week because our winter has been mild so far. Well, winter is now here and I pulled these out to wear and they are FABULOUS! I adore them!! I am plus sized and the elastic in the calf is PERFECT. The fur is so cozy and the foot bed very comfy. Because they are not leather, the ankle is a little stiff, but I can live with that. Like others say, they do run tall. I am 5'6" and I wish they were perhaps an inch shorter. It is bearable, but it takes a little getting used to. While riding, you feel the "over tallness" of them less, so that's a good thing. Also, I usually ride in suede half chaps and am not used to smooth boots, which are slippery and make me feel less secure. These boots are grippier than my half chaps and I LOVE them for this! Oh man give me a leather tall boot with a calf grip like this and I'd wear them forever!! I think they are priced fairly. They are not cheap, but I think the price is perfectly fine for this boot. I can't wait to wear these again!"
Products related to my content
Review 7 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Warm Boots, Great Fit
January 17, 2013
ByKayOTTB
fromOH
I have used this product for:1-3 months
Expertise:Intermediate
Riding Style:Leisure/Trail Riding - English
Competitor:Non-competitor
Quality:
4
of
5
Value:
5
of
5
Durability:
5
of
5
Share this Review:
"The zipper irritated my heels on the first day out. But after that, I wore thicker socks, and these boots have been fantastic. The shaft height is great (I'm 5'9"), they keep my legs and feet warm, and I've received several compliments on how they look."
Review 8 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Worth it!
January 13, 2013
ByBMCMouse
fromWeymouth, MA
I have used this product for:less than a month
Expertise:Expert
Riding Style:All Around
Competitor:Local/Open
Quality:
5
of
5
Value:
5
of
5
Durability:
5
of
5
Fit
Runs small
Runs large
Just right
Share this Review:
"I have never been a fan of tall boots, but my workboots (which I regularly wear riding) needed to be replaced. I decided to buy these boots for warmth and waterproof qualities, as I also do work in the barn.
The biggest con I found was that the zippers were a BEAST to zip up. But once I had them on, they were so comfortable, I forgot I was wearing tall boots! I have worn them every day for a week, and have found that they zip up fine now; I believe the elasticity has more give now, and I can zipper with no problem. I also like how the soft material around the ankle makes keeping my heel down in the stirrup ultra easy! And it doesn't hurt that they are stylin' too!
I do not find the boots too tall at all, and I am only 5'3" tall. Can't go wrong buying at SmartPak with their 100% satisfaction guarantee. :-)"
The biggest con I found was that the zippers were a BEAST to zip up. But once I had them on, they were so comfortable, I forgot I was wearing tall boots! I have worn them every day for a week, and have found that they zip up fine now; I believe the elasticity has more give now, and I can zipper with no problem. I also like how the soft material around the ankle makes keeping my heel down in the stirrup ultra easy! And it doesn't hurt that they are stylin' too!
I do not find the boots too tall at all, and I am only 5'3" tall. Can't go wrong buying at SmartPak with their 100% satisfaction guarantee. :-)"
Products related to my content
On Course Cotton Naturals™ Full Seat Breeches
(16)Review 9 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Worth every penny
January 13, 2013
Bydpaintedpink
fromColorado
I have used this product for:less than a month
Expertise:Intermediate
Riding Style:All Around
Competitor:Rated
Quality:
5
of
5
Value:
5
of
5
Durability:
5
of
5
Share this Review:
"I'd been eyeing these boots for a long time before purchasing them and I love them! It's so nice to have warm feet while I ride."
Review 10 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Toasty Warm!
January 4, 2013
ByBraeMont
fromEast Tennessee
I have used this product for:1-2 years
Expertise:Trainer
Riding Style:Eventing
Competitor:Rated
Quality:
5
of
5
Value:
5
of
5
Durability:
5
of
5
Share this Review:
Review 11 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
GOOD FOR RIDING
November 30, 2012
ByJEM79
fromMid-Atlantic
I have used this product for:1-3 months
Expertise:Intermediate
Riding Style:Dressage
Competitor:Rated
Quality:
4
of
5
Value:
4
of
5
Durability:
5
of
5
Share this Review:
"When I looked at reviews it was difficult to figure out whether people were just wearing these around the barn/town, or actually in the saddle.
YOU CAN RIDE IN THESE.
There, I've said it. They're warm, comfortable, and attractive, but I bought them to ride in because my feet were cold.
While the sole is a bit thick ie more heavily treaded than a normal field or dress boot, I did not find this to be a problem. Interestingly, I find they ride more like a dressage boot, rather than a dress or field boot. The ankle is much less flexible, more stable, which works for me. Unlike a dressage boot, however, YOU CAN ALSO WALK IN THEM. Break-in time was nonexistent and I've had no trouble with rubbing. While they aren't particularly streamlined, I am still able to wear spurs with them."
Review 12 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Warmest toes in town
November 26, 2012
ByJanyse
fromDouglassville, PA
I have used this product for:less than a month
Expertise:Expert
Riding Style:Leisure/Trail Riding - Western
Competitor:Non-competitor
Quality:
5
of
5
Value:
5
of
5
Durability:
5
of
5
Share this Review:
"I LOVE Mountain Horse products! I'm never disappointed in their quality, fit and durability. My latest acquisition, the Stella Polaris winter riding boots have kept my feet warm and dry in 27 degree weather. THe full faux fur lining from toes to top of boot is a wind-buster!! I only wore regular crew socks, not my normal smart wool winter hiking socks and my feet were toasty the whole 3 hour ride! Highly recommend if you're a winter rider. I have LONG legs (34" inseam and they come to just below my knee)"
My Photos
(click to see full-size image)
Review 13 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Did not like.
February 8, 2012
ByDACRider
fromCoast of NC
I have used this product for:less than a month
Expertise:Expert
Riding Style:Leisure/Trail Riding - English
Competitor:Non-competitor
Quality:
4
of
5
Value:
3
of
5
Durability:
4
of
5
Fit
Excellent
Share this Review:
"Looking for a comfortable, warm, tall winter riding boot. Have tried many. This boot along with several others was immediately uncomfortable when I tried it on and walked around my living room. The fit at the ankle was very uncomfortable and the height on the leg was way too high. It would take some time to break in. On the positive side the feel and fit of the foot part was very good. I am of average height (5'6") and leg length is average. Mountain Horse boots seem to run tall and are bent a bit to fit better when you are sitting on your horse. Purchased the Blizzard below and love it."
Review 14 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Ripped after being worn a few times.
February 7, 2012
ByJunie
fromSE Pennsylvania
I have used this product for:1-3 months
Expertise:Novice
Riding Style:Leisure/Trail Riding - English
Competitor:Non-competitor
Quality:
2
of
5
Value:
2
of
5
Durability:
1
of
5
Fit
Excellent
Share this Review:
"I wore these boots no more than six times since purchasing them this year. Last week after brushing into the wall of the inside riding ring I realized there was a 3+ inch tear down the front of my left boot. Sometimes everyday riding boots get some abuse. I would hope a pair of boots the cost almost $200 would hold up better than this. I have an older pair if Rimfrost boots that seem a lot tougher but not very comfortable which is why I purchased the Stella polaris style. I won't be buying another pair."
Review 15 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
I love these boots
February 3, 2012
ByBeamer
fromDouglassville, PA
I have used this product for:less than a month
Expertise:Trainer
Riding Style:Dressage
Competitor:Local/Open
Quality:
5
of
5
Value:
5
of
5
Durability:
5
of
5
Share this Review:
"I wore these boots for 4 hours both riding and teaching outdoors. My legs and toes were toasty the whole time."
Review 16 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Too tall
January 18, 2012
Byriorojo
fromHigh Point, NC
I have used this product for:less than a month
Expertise:Intermediate
Riding Style:Leisure/Trail Riding - Western
Competitor:Local/Open
Quality:
4
of
5
Value:
4
of
5
Durability:
4
of
5
Fit
Excellent
Share this Review:
"I liked the boots, but had to return because they were way too tall. Hit me in the middle of my knee cap. I'm 5'6" tall. Not sure if this is a brand thing or not. Ordered some boots from another company and they fit great. Mountain Horse may just have super tall boots."
Review 17 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
great boot, but too tall
January 16, 2012
ByTh8nkful
fromIndiana
I have used this product for:1-3 months
Expertise:Novice
Riding Style:Leisure/Trail Riding - English
Competitor:Non-competitor
Quality:
5
of
5
Value:
5
of
5
Durability:
5
of
5
Fit
Excellent
Share this Review:
"I wear a 10.5 or 11... bought this boot (elsewhere) in 11 Wide Calf, and the foot length is a smidgen long, but I think a 10 would be too small. Like other MH boots I've tried, the calf length is very tall, much too tall for me, and I'm average height (5'6"). But since I got these elsewhere and shipping wasn't free, and since I liked everything else about the boot so much, decided to keep them, and my solution is that I just don't snap the boot or zip up the zipper all the way, I leave it an inch or two from the top, and the zipper stays up fine. I know, probably looks a little goofy, but since they are winter boots after all, it works. I put in heel lifts too. My calves are 16" and I'm glad I got the Wide Calf, probably the regular wouldn't have worked over winter breeches and socks. I still have some room in the calf, probably a 17" or maybe even wider calf could fit this boot. A very warm, functional boot, works great, feels great, and looks cute-- I get a lot of compliments, even with my goofy partially zipped zippers, LOL! I have no problems with them in English stirrups, but in Western stirrups they are a little difficult to manage, I have to bend over and help my foot into the stirrup sometimes. Would highly recommend these, especially if you have l-o-n-g legs."
Products related to my content
Review 18 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Good-looking boots, warm feet, but issues with fit
January 12, 2012
ByColorado
fromCO
I have used this product for:1-3 months
Expertise:Intermediate
Riding Style:Eventing
Competitor:Local/Open
Quality:
3
of
5
Value:
5
of
5
Fit
Excellent
Share this Review:
"I would love to give these boots an even higher rating, but have had issues with the fit. But first, let me start with what I love about them:
* For the first time, I have warm feet while riding in the winter! Oh, what a difference these boots make! On a recent "warmish" day (near 40 degrees), I switched to my regular boots, and was reminded just how cold my feet get while riding in non-insulated boots.
* I feel very fashion-forward while wearing these boots, and have received several compliments (and "where did you buy those?" inquiries) about them.
* Although the exterior boot material is not leather, the material lining the inner legs provides just the right amount of "stick" against the saddle.
* Fit issues notwithstanding, the boots are comfortable to wear right out of the box, with a nice, fuzzy lining that makes me feel impervious to cold!
* For the first time, I have warm feet while riding in the winter! Oh, what a difference these boots make! On a recent "warmish" day (near 40 degrees), I switched to my regular boots, and was reminded just how cold my feet get while riding in non-insulated boots.
* I feel very fashion-forward while wearing these boots, and have received several compliments (and "where did you buy those?" inquiries) about them.
* Although the exterior boot material is not leather, the material lining the inner legs provides just the right amount of "stick" against the saddle.
* Fit issues notwithstanding, the boots are comfortable to wear right out of the box, with a nice, fuzzy lining that makes me feel impervious to cold!
Okay, now for the not-so-good aspects:
* These boots run LARGE! I normally wear a size 9.5 in regular shoes, but often go down to 8.5 in riding boots. I ordered these in size 8, and have belatedly realized that they are still too big. Compounding the problem is the "rough" stitching where the zipper is sewn into the back of the boot. Since my heel rubs against the back of the boot somewhat as I walk, I have been having trouble with getting blisters at the point of the rub.
* Little gripe: For some reason, it's kind of hard to snap up the snaps. But, other than that, the boots are very easy to get on."
* These boots run LARGE! I normally wear a size 9.5 in regular shoes, but often go down to 8.5 in riding boots. I ordered these in size 8, and have belatedly realized that they are still too big. Compounding the problem is the "rough" stitching where the zipper is sewn into the back of the boot. Since my heel rubs against the back of the boot somewhat as I walk, I have been having trouble with getting blisters at the point of the rub.
* Little gripe: For some reason, it's kind of hard to snap up the snaps. But, other than that, the boots are very easy to get on."
Review 19 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Love these boots!
January 11, 2012
ByWinsomeWay
fromOH
I have used this product for:1-3 months
Expertise:Novice
Riding Style:Leisure/Trail Riding - English
Competitor:Non-competitor
Quality:
5
of
5
Value:
5
of
5
Durability:
5
of
5
Fit
Excellent
Share this Review:
"They keep my feet nice and warm without the need for extra socks. A winter must!"
Review 20 for Mountain Horse Stella Polaris Tall Boot
Overall Rating:
Very warm boots
January 4, 2012
ByBrandy19
fromsouthern massachusetts
I have used this product for:less than a month
Expertise:Intermediate
Riding Style:Dressage
Competitor:Non-competitor
Quality:
5
of
5
Value:
4
of
5
Durability:
4
of
5
Fit
Excellent
Share this Review:
"Snug through ankle but roomy in calf. Very comfortable boots to both walk and ride in."